 | PANELBY: MARINA PILIPOVIĆ |
1. problem
Team, All |
|
3  : 103  : 73  : 32 NT: 2 |
Aljoša:
3 - 100%.
Kao i obično treba odabrati najmanje zlo jer nijedan od licita ne odgovara u potpunosti. Dva bez bez štopera karo, tri tref sa ovako šupljim trefom ili četvrta boja forsing.
Tri tref je forsing, mora biti nakon dva pik, koji nam ostavlja najviše prostora da ispitamo koju manšu ćemo igrati. Ako treba igrati u bezadutu želim da igra partner.
Andy:
3 - 100%.
Bato:
3 - 100%.
rađe bi licitirao 2 trefa ali ne mogu.
Brk:
3 - 100%.
Iako je tref loš mislim da je to najmanje zlo. Ostavlja otvorene mogućnosti za eventualnu manšu u majoru ili 4-3 ili 5-2 fitu ili 5 trefa. Tri karo ne dolazi u obzir. Općenito, list je, što bi dabas rekli «bljak» i, iako to nije današnja tema, odgovor 1NT jako dolazi u obzir. Ne želim licitirati 2NT bez štopera karo.
Danilo:
3 - 100%.
Jos nemam dovoljno informacija. 3NT cu pasirati, a na ev 4Tref cu reci 4Herc.
Dubo:
3 - 100%.
Eddie Kantar:
3 - 70%.
3 - 30%.
3H 70% If partner has a diamond stopper, partner can bid 3NT. After all, partner knows I know he has five hearts.
3D 30% I have a little sympathy (but not much) for this bid.
Haig Tchamitch:
2 NT - 90%.
3 - 10%.
Why oh why did I bid 2C on this hand and not 1NT?
Ivica:
3 - 100%.
Neka partner kaže 3NT ako može.
Marina:
3 - 80%.
3 - 20%.
Max:
3 - 100%.
trying to find bettr contract
Nikica:
3 - 100%.
Paul:
3 - 50%.
2 NT - 50%.
I'm not sure how far forcing 2NT is after this sequence - if it is Forcing then it gives partner a chance of making a descriptive bid. If 2NT is NOT forcing then 3H is the only bid I can think of.
Šenk:
3 - 100%.
Tipicen problem, ce ne igras 1NT forcing. No, kar je, je, zaradi teamskega obracuna bi licitiral 3 karo (4th F) in v primeru, da partner nima stoperja bi se obsodil na 3 NT.
Špiljak:
3 - 100%.
Možda i nemamo manšu, ali bi mi bilo drago čuti partnerovih 3NT. Ako ne licitira 3 pik, igraćemo 4 herc.
Todi:
3 - 100%.
ako 3 herc ne bi bio forcing (a mislim, da bi sada trebao biti), onda bi licitirao 3 herc
2. problem
Pair, All |
|
3 : 10 3 : 3pass: 3 4 : 24 : 14 : 1 |
Aljoša: pass - 100%. Još nije potpuno jasno da li su protivnici možda u misfitu. Pričekat ću da vidim što se događa jer ne želim olako propustiti šansu za +200. Nadam se da će mi sve biti jasno nakon partnerovog licita i da neće biti previše kasno.
Andy:
4 - 100%.
I have to show partner my second suit, so that he can evaluate his hand better, if the opponents will bid on
Bato:
3 - 100%.
to sam licitirao i za stolom. Ostalo znate iz prošlog DJ.
Brk:
3 - 100%.
Prirodno, možda dugi trial. Možda imamo manšu. Možda protivnici imaju manšu. Možda obje strane imaju manšu. Ako su HP raspodijeljeni otprilike 20:20 ne želim biti pasivan s ovim tipom lista.
Danilo:
4 - 100%.
Zelim tref ataku na ev. 4P. S druge strane, 3Tref je preopasno (partner moze krivo procijeniti list). 3 Herc vjerojatno nije dovoljno, jer ce se protivnici javiti. Pass pa kasnija ocijena je vjerojatno prekasno. Svaki licit je opasan, jer su protivnici mozda u mis-fitu, ali mislim da je vise vjerojatno da ipak imaju tref-fit. 3 karo ne zelim reci, jer ne zelim ev. krivu ataku. Nakon 4 trefa, iako nije najbolji kontrakt, mozda 4H nece biti kontrirano.
Dubo:
3 - 100%.
Eddie Kantar:
3 - 100%.
It is usually right to show your second suit in competitive auctions.
Haig Tchamitch:
3 - 80%.
3 - 20%.
The only danger of bidding 3D is that the opponents might well realize what a good fit they have in clubs. More often than not, I think partner will need the information to either bid game or potentially double the opponents
Ivica:
3 - 100%.
Može se baražirati, ali je bolje da partner vidi što se događa na bordu.
Marina:
3 - 60%.
4 - 30%.
4 - 10%.
Max:
3 - 90%.
4 - 10%.
My pd nust know what we must do over opponents 4 spades or 5 clubs, so i prefer to describe my hand
Nikica:
3 - 70%.
dble - 30%.
Paul:
3 - 70%.
4 - 30%.
It is usually right to show your second suit on these two-suited hands so that partner can judge how high to bid. The alternative of 4C (for the lead) has some appeal but I think it more important to bid out my shape. After all, if partner has 5 Diamonds as well both sides can make lots of tricks. I think 4H a really silly bid - North may well bid 4S and then what do you do after two passes?
Šenk:
3 - 100%.
Recimo, da imamo fit. Ce mi je ze omogoceno, da lahko igram naravno, bo na paru 3 karo kar dovolj.
Špiljak: pass - 100%. Ionako bi pasirao 2 herc. Partner možda kontrira 3 tref a tada ću razmižljati. Možda mi završe u 5 karo u kontri (he-he).
Todi:
3 - 50%.
4 - 40%.
4 - 10%.
3. problem
Pair, None |
|
dble: 10 1 NT: 9 pass: 5 1 spade: 1 |
Aljoša: dble - 100%. Usprkos štoperu i petnaest poena jedan bez mi se ne sviđa iz razloga što lijevi protivnik atakira na jedan bezaduta i protivnici su učas razvili tref. . Kontra nije školska sa samo dva karona ali ja se nadam da cxu pronaći majorski fit.
Andy: dble - 100%. you have a bad position for 1NT; partner often has the Q of clubs and you play NT from the wrong hand, if y overcall 1NT
Bato: 1 NT - 100%. i to sam licitirao za stolom, ali ne znate da su me kontrirali i da sam pao za 500 i dobio zasluženu nulu. I pass je dobar licit, puno puta.
Brk: dble - 100%. Na 1 karo licitiram 1 pik, na 1 herc, 1 pik i 1NT pass. Eventualnih 1 pik ili 1NT smatram lošijim izborom.
Danilo: 1 NT - 100%. Teska srca sa ovim listom (Vise volim 1NT 16-19). Opcija je i pass pa kasniji licit. Kontra mi se ne dopada bez obzira na 4-3 majore.
Dubo: pass - 100%.
Eddie Kantar: dble - 100%. I can see no good reason not to double with this hand.
Haig Tchamitch: pass - 90%. 1 NT - 10%. Both 1NT and a takeout double are pretty awful. You have no trick structure for 1NT, and a 2D bid by partner after your LHO bids a major will cause partner to throw up when dummy comes down.
Ivica: 1 NT - 100%. Parski.
Marina: 1 spade - 60%. 1 NT - 30%. dble - 10%.
Max: 1 NT - 100%. natural
Nikica: dble - 80%. 1 NT - 20%.
Paul: 1 NT - 70%. pass - 30%. What choice is there? A slightly weak 1NT or a conservative Pass. I don't rate Double at all and I NEVER overcall with a 4 card suit. Pairs is a bidder's game - so 1NT it is.
Šenk: pass - 100%. Po mojem pridem se na vrsto zato ne bom kontriral. Brez T in le kolikor toliko lepim pikom pa roka ni za 1 NT.
Špiljak: 1 NT - 100%. Uvjeren sam da je prirodni 1NT overcall licitacija koju treba koristiti ako se ikako može. Ovo vrijedi pogotovo na paru.
Todi: dble - 100%. ovo sam licitirao za stolom i čini mi se bolja alternativa od passa (1pik i 1NT)
4. problem
Team, All |
|
3 : 10 5 : 63 NT: 3 |
Aljoša:
5 - 60%.
3 - 30%.
3 NT - 10%.
Da li sa smješkom pokušati ukrasti ili licitirati korektno. Ali što to korektno licitirati?
Pet karo odmah ili možda tri herc sa nadom da partner neće potvrditi sa dvije karte. Ako partner ima duplog herc kralja unutra je barem pet karo, a tri bez i četiri herc su gotovo bez šanse.
Andy:
3 - 100%.
perhaps partner can bid 3Spades, then I bid 3NT; if he bids something else, I bid 5D
Bato:
3 - 100%.
3 pik od baražera mora biti štoper pik (ili licitira 3 NT ako ga ima - dogovor) tako da je omiljeni kontrakt još uvije moguć. Na 4 herca licitiram 5 karo. Partner sa singlom pik može još "potegnuti" npr. sa: x, Kxx, K1098xxx, Kx
Brk:
3 - 100%.
Ako partner kaže 4 herca, licitiram 5 karo. Ako licitira 4 trefa (cue bid za herc) probat ću s 4 karo, dobiti još informacija. Partnerovih 3 NT pokazuje pik štopera, partnerovih 3 pika traži pik štopera i pokazuje tref štopera. Partnerovih 4 karo negira crnog štopera i pokazuje slab list – pasiram. Ne želim reći 3NT i gledati protivnike dok mi uzimaju 5 pikova dok je 5 karo u glavu.
Danilo: 3 NT - 100%. 9 stihova je vjerojatnije od 5Karo (11). Ja ne volim baraze sa poenima sa strane. Moguc licit je i 3 Herc (moza mozemo igrati 4 Herc u 4-3 fitu, ali tada je losa distribucija moguca. osim toga, tko kaze da ce N imati Pik ataku.
Dubo:
3 - 100%.
Eddie Kantar:
3 - 100%.
At teams, I can't bear to play 3NT facing a singleton or small doubleton in spades with 5 or 6 diamonds cold.
Haig Tchamitch:
5 - 90%.
3 NT - 10%.
3NT is a big gamble. Yes it might work out when partner has something like Jxx, x , KQxxxxx, x and he can't guess which finesse to take. But then, you don't have to play it do you ?
Ivica:
3 - 100%.
Partner je otvorio na prvom mjestu pa treba pokušati igrati manšu.
Marina:
5 - 70%.
3 - 20%.
3 NT - 10%.
Max:
5 - 100%.
Of course 3 diamonds promises 7 cards in first position vulnerable; so if 3 nt is cold (k or a of spades and 7 diamonds) also 5 diam is a good contract
Nikica:
5 - 80%.
3 - 20%.
Paul:
5 - 90%.
3 NT - 10%.
A vulnerable partner should have a decent hand in first seat but 6D looks to be a long way away. 3NT might make (if partner has, say, J x x in Spades) but I much prefer the security of 5D, especially at teams.
Šenk: 3 NT - 100%. Tega ne znam drugace licitirati (tudi za mizo sem tole licitiral 3 NT, ceprav je v igri 5 kar, partner pa je brez pika).
Špiljak:
3 - 80%.
3 NT - 20%.
Igrao bih 3NT. Filozofije ok 5 karo su za filozofe (i za mene ako partner potvrdi herc). Ajmo reć da protivnici atakiraju pik i skupe prvih 6 štihova - peh.
Todi:
3 - 100%.
3H ostavlja otvorene sve opcije
5. problem
Pair, NS vul |
|
dble: 10 pass: 3 4 : 24  : 14 : 15 NT: 0 |
Aljoša: pass - 70%. dble - 30%. Ne znam sxto bi licitirao pa pasiram uz uvjerenje da je pass forsing.I da nije forsing ne znam što bih licitirao. Sa većinom poena u majorima ne sviđa mi se kaznena kontra samo sa trećom tref damom gdje partner vjerovatno ima singl.Ako mi nemamo herc fit gotovo sigurno imamo pik fit koji je sada jako teško pronaći. Nadam se da će partner ispravno shvatiti moj pass i donijeti pravu odluku.
Andy: dble - 100%.
Bato: dble - 100%. i atakiram trefa. Malo me još boli ruka pa sam bio malo kraći nego obično.
Brk: dble - 100%. Ako partner pasira atakiram tref, a kada nadrežem stol ponovo vratim tref. Pass mi izgleda kao «Brigo moja pređi na drugoga»
Danilo: dble - 100%. Vjerujem u bar 500 (bolje od manse). ne mogu pasirati, jer partner sigurno ne moze kontrirati. Ako imamo ev. slam, vjerujem da ce pasti bar 1100.
Dubo: pass - 100%.
Eddie Kantar: dble - 60%. pass - 40%. Dbl: 60% (I wish I had been playing Flannery). Partner has diamonds so if declarer has diamond length we will take quite a few defensive tricks. If declarer is short in diamonds, trump leads ought to be very effective. In the final analysis, it is the vulnerability that tempts me. Pass: 40% I don't like doubling with such poor clubs and such a good chance of having a spade fit, but I'm not sure we are going to find our spade fit if I pass. Again, I wish I were playing Flannery
Haig Tchamitch: dble - 90%. pass - 10%. You pretty much have to double and lead a trump, even tho I suspect you might be missing a 4S game. Oh well.
Ivica: dble - 100%. 4pika je vjerojatno unutra ali pretpostavljam lošu distribuciju.
Marina:
dble - 70%.
pass - 20%.
4 - 10%.
Max: dble - 100%. i propose to penalty (leading clubs of course)
Nikica: dble - 100%.
Paul:
4 - 80%.
pass - 20%.
I would pass if I thought it was forcing but I'm not sure that it is. South seems to have 4 Clubs (marking partner with only a singleton). 4D must be the most flexible bid, forcing East to choose between the majors.
Šenk: dble - 100%. Tudi znan board. Mislim, da je kontra kar prava licitacija.
Špiljak:
dble - 50%.
4 - 50%.
Ako protivnici nisu potpuni manijaci onda misle da bi se od nečega trebali braniti. Oba majora ne mogu pokazati ali herc mogu. Ako ne želim filozofirati tada kontriram (i atakiram puba karo).
Todi: dble - 100%. za kontru ne trebam imati puno više od treće tref figure
| EXPERT | PROBLEM 1 | PROBLEM 2 | PROBLEM 3 | PROBLEM 4 | PROBLEM 5 | TOTAL |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Miljenko Brkljačić | 7.0 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 47.0 |
| Ivica Miladin | 7.0 | 10.0 | 9.0 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 46.0 |
| Bato Protega | 7.0 | 10.0 | 9.0 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 46.0 |
| Todi Gantar | 10.0 | 5.6 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 45.6 |
| Massimo Morits | 10.0 | 9.1 | 9.0 | 6.0 | 10.0 | 44.1 |
| Eddie Kantar | 5.1 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 7.2 | 42.3 |
| Nikica Šver | 10.0 | 2.1 | 9.8 | 6.8 | 10.0 | 38.7 |
| Matija Šenk | 10.0 | 10.0 | 5.0 | 3.0 | 10.0 | 38.0 |
| Andy Gloyer | 7.0 | 1.0 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 10.0 | 38.0 |
| Branko Špiljak | 10.0 | 3.0 | 9.0 | 8.6 | 5.5 | 36.1 |
| Marina Pilipović | 9.4 | 6.4 | 4.3 | 6.5 | 7.7 | 34.3 |
| Danilo Stojanović | 10.0 | 2.0 | 9.0 | 3.0 | 10.0 | 34.0 |
| Aljoša Čakić | 7.0 | 3.0 | 10.0 | 6.9 | 5.1 | 32.0 |
| Haig Tchamitch | 2.5 | 8.6 | 5.4 | 5.7 | 9.3 | 31.5 |
| Paul Bowyer | 2.5 | 7.6 | 7.8 | 5.7 | 2.2 | 25.8 |
| Dubravko Diklić | 3.0 | 3.0 | 5.0 | 10.0 | 3.0 | 24.0 |
| CONTESTANT | PROBLEM 1 | PROBLEM 2 | PROBLEM 3 | PROBLEM 4 | PROBLEM 5 | TOTAL |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zoran Šantek | 3 = 10 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 = 10 |
dble = 10 | 49 |
| Dražen Martinović | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
dble = 10 | 3 = 10 |
dble = 10 | 47 |
| Igor Novosel | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 = 10 |
dble = 10 | 46 |
| Tolja Orač | 3 = 10 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 45 |
| Frano Jančić | 3 = 10 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 45 |
| Srđan Katušić | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 42 |
| Željka Karaman-Martinović | 3 = 10 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 = 10 |
pass = 3 | 42 |
| Adriano Voscilla | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 42 |
| Miro Novak | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 42 |
| Miro Tesla | 2 NT = 2 | 3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 = 10 |
dble = 10 | 41 |
| Milko Pravdić | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 = 10 |
pass = 3 | 39 |
| Karlo Brguljan | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 NT = 3 | dble = 10 | 39 |
| Sandra Ruso | 3 = 10 |
pass = 3 | 1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 38 |
| Pero Stojančević | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
dble = 10 | 4 NT = 0 | dble = 10 | 37 |
| Milan Žmak | 3 = 10 |
4 = 1 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 36 |
| Nenad Poštić | 3 = 10 |
pass = 3 | dble = 10 | 3 = 10 |
pass = 3 | 36 |
| Zoran Bohaček | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
pass = 3 | 35 |
| Helga Poklepović | 3 = 0 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 35 |
| Simon Pirjevec | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
pass = 3 | 35 |
| Alen Perković | 3 = 0 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 35 |
| Aleksandar Mixich | 3 = 7 |
3 = 3 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 35 |
| Dean Pokorny | 3 = 7 |
4 = 2 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 34 |
| Boris Bursać | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 spade = 1 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 34 |
| Tomislav Šašek | 2 NT = 2 | 3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 = 10 |
4 = 2 |
33 |
| Barbara Kranjc | 3 = 10 |
3 = 3 |
dble = 10 | pass = 0 | dble = 10 | 33 |
| Duško Obradović | 3 = 7 |
pass = 3 | 1 NT = 9 | 3 NT = 3 | dble = 10 | 32 |
| Aleksandar Carević | 3 = 10 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 4 = 0 |
pass = 3 | 32 |
| Dragan Petrina | 3 = 0 |
pass = 3 | 1 NT = 9 | 3 = 10 |
dble = 10 | 32 |
| Dario Filjar | 3 = 10 |
pass = 3 | pass = 5 | 3 NT = 3 | dble = 10 | 31 |
| Tvrtko Perković | 3 = 10 |
4 = 1 |
dble = 10 | 4 = 0 |
dble = 10 | 31 |
| Marija Orešković | 3 = 10 |
3 = 3 |
dble = 10 | 5 = 6 |
4 = 1 |
30 |
| Zoran Potočki | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 NT = 3 | 4 = 1 |
30 |
| Marijan Praljak | 3 = 3 |
3 = 10 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
4 = 2 |
30 |
| Iva Jurišić | 3 = 7 |
3 = 3 |
dble = 10 | 5 = 6 |
pass = 3 | 29 |
| Gjivo Tikvica | 3 = 3 |
pass = 3 | dble = 10 | 3 = 10 |
pass = 3 | 29 |
| Dragan Visekrunić | 2 NT = 2 | pass = 3 | dble = 10 | 3 NT = 3 | dble = 10 | 28 |
| Renata Muller | 3 = 7 |
3 = 3 |
pass = 5 | 3 = 10 |
pass = 3 | 28 |
| Ljubica Bajakić | 2 NT = 2 | 3 = 3 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 = 10 |
pass = 3 | 27 |
| Boris Hajduković | 3 NT = 0 | 3 = 3 |
dble = 10 | 3 NT = 3 | dble = 10 | 26 |
| Tomislav Bošnjak | 3 = 10 |
4 = 1 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 NT = 3 | pass = 3 | 26 |
| Dominik Mokni | 3 = 0 |
4 = 1 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
dble = 10 | 26 |
| Natko Sorić | 3 = 7 |
pass = 3 | 1 NT = 9 | 3 NT = 3 | pass = 3 | 25 |
| Igor Mandalinic | 3 = 0 |
3 = 3 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 NT = 3 | dble = 10 | 25 |
| Danijel Zenko | 3 = 7 |
3 = 3 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 NT = 3 | pass = 3 | 25 |
| Vanja Grahek | 3 = 7 |
4 = 1 |
1 NT = 9 | 3 NT = 3 | pass = 3 | 23 |
| Srđan Richter | 3 = 0 |
3 = 3 |
dble = 10 | 4 NT = 0 | dble = 10 | 23 |
| Vesna Dacić | 3 = 7 |
3 = 10 |
1 spade = 1 | 3 NT = 3 | 4 = 1 |
22 |
| Alan Pavičić | 3 = 0 |
3 = 3 |
1 NT = 9 | 5 = 6 |
pass = 3 | 21 |
| Boris Ferić | 4 = 0 |
pass = 3 | dble = 10 | 3 NT = 3 | pass = 3 | 19 |
| Mario Zeljko | 3 NT = 0 | pass = 3 | 1 NT = 9 | 3 NT = 3 | pass = 3 | 18 |
| Branimir Zauner | 3 = 7 |
4 = 1 |
1 NT = 9 | 4 NT = 0 | 4 = 1 |
18 |
| Zlatko Unetić | 3 = 7 |
4 = 1 |
1 spade = 1 | 5 = 6 |
4 = 1 |
16 |
| Marin Poklepović | 3 = 0 |
4 = 1 |
pass = 5 | 5 = 6 |
pass = 3 | 15 |
| Damir Franulović | 2 NT = 2 | 3 = 0 |
1 NT = 9 | 4 = 0 |
4 = 1 |
12 |